Wednesday, May 11, 2011

RAJ


I'm not really sure when or why it happened, but nowadays no one can ever just finish out their contract. There has to be a contract extension, a trade or a firing. It is now assumed if you complete your contract you will have a new employer the following season. I understand sometimes these things are warranted. Like when Ryan Howard was granted an extension, I won't say I agree with the decision but I completely understand the rational. He was signed in an effort to get him at a fair market value before Pujols and Prince Fielder were signed to some ridiculous contracts that would in turn put Howard's value out of the Phillies budget.

One case I don't see the benefit is with regards to Ruben Amaro Jr. Now, before you get your panties in a bunch, I think Rubes has done a fine job. There isn't too much I can find fault with in the way he has handled the Phillies since he replaced Pat Gillick. Sure, there is the Cliff Lee trade to Seattle, but Lee is a Phillie again. And what some people fail to realize is that had he not made the trade who is to say the Phillies don't become sellers last July when they were 7 games out. Meaning no Roy Oswalt and Lee would have packed his bags anyhow.

But I also urge you to realized the core of this team was built by one of Philly's favorite whipping boys, Ed Wade. Wade built a team that could and did contend. What he failed to do was put his neck on the line to make a trade that could put them over the top. Seems like Amaro learned this lesson on his own. Amaro's strengths have been his trades and free agent signings.  But when you look closer, the assets he traded away were drafted by Wade and then Pat Gillick. I don't know the specifics of what budgets Wade, Gillick or Amaro were dictated in regards to payroll, but I’m sure all three maximized their allotted payroll meaning the current financial state of the Phillies allows Amaro the most payroll flexibility in team history.

Its easy to win Monopoly if you start the game with hotels on Boardwalk and Park Place. It takes more than 2 years to prove that you are competent G.M. Let alone a great one. Trades especially those that involve prospects take years to evaluate properly. Drafts take even longer to assess. So basically before you anoint RAJ the greatest G.M. in the history of baseball, let's get all the facts or at least a right-handed power outfielder.

See ya at the ballpark!

Jay Wrizight
jaywrizight@yahoo.com

7 comments:

  1. You give Ed Wade too much credit. His group were the Abreu's, Lieberthal's, the Gavin Floyd's. He did lay the ground work but it took Pat Gillick to add the finishing touches, Blanton at the trade deadline in 08, trading for Lidge before 08. Rube was handed the keys to a Rolls Royce for sure.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Looks like he is laying the ground work in Houston!!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. too much credit? I said he built the core. You forgot he drafted Hamels, Victorino (rule 5), Myers, Howard, Burrell and Utley. I also said he "failed" to put them over the top. And Lieberthal was drafted by LEE THOMAS and so was your boy Abreu (in the expansion draft).

    ReplyDelete
  4. I swore Amaro said he traded Lee away because he was anticipating a huge pay date and said the Phils couldn't afford it. Then a few months later they pay Howard $121 mill (which I thought was excessive, but compared to what Werth got...it was a bargain). Then we end up resigning Lee for money money than we originally anticipated. So I agree with your premise on Amaro, but for different reasons.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bobby was acquired in a trade for Kevin Stocker

    ReplyDelete
  6. abreau was drafted to the D-Rays and then traded but it was all orchestrated by the evil Lee Thomas.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nah, Amaro traded away Lee because he wanted to retool the farm system. I still believe it was a money issue why he was traded.

    ReplyDelete